My short story collection is coming out in a week, and I have new workshops you can still sign up for!
If you want to write your novel next year? I got you covered with Pioneer Valley Writers Workshop's 10-month Manuscript program: https://www.pioneervalleywriters.org/application-for-manuscript-program-2026
Looking to just jumpstart your short fiction in the new year? I'll be teaching "6 Weeks, 6 Stories" over at GrubStreet: https://grubstreet.org/workshop/6-weeks-6-stories-medeiros-w27
###
Anyway, what's obviously needed now is to discuss a forty year-old X-Men graphic novel.
So Iman Vellani, who plays Miss Marvel, recently recommended the Chris Claremont classic God Loves, Man Kill in an interview, and it occurred to me that I've never actually read this one. I got it from my local library and…it holds up.
It's really good. The team is great, with a lot of favorites (Kurt is here!), even if Cyclops and Storm are kidnapped and sidelined for most of it.
What really stands out is, of course, the villain, Stryker–a televangelist who is using his pulpit to foment religiously-motivated mutant hatred. He's a murderer, but he justifies it all with a clear misreading of the Bible. It's not subtle. You can see how Stryker's style clearly reflects the bigotry of televangelists popular when the book was published in 1982–and still popular today. He's scarier than most of the supervillains because his power is one that exists in our world: the power to persuade and motivate. There's a bunch to say here about how this anticipates and/or reflects the mis-use of massive media apparatuses by neo-fascists, but the comparison should be obvious enough on its own, and I'll leave it there.
But what interests me most is how dark GLMK is NOT. It's remembered as being one of the bleakest X-Men stories. And, sure, that makes sense. Professor X is tortured horrifically by Stryker, and the hallucinations he suffers during that sequence remain pretty horrific years later. The thematic content is clearly dealing with explicitly political themes. And Kitty Pryde, making any possible subtext very much just text, uses the n-word when explaining the prejudice that mutants face. In the end, a traumatized Charles almost considers going over to Magneto's way of thinking before Cyclops pulls him back to the side of the angels.
At the same time, though, Stryker's rhetoric is always met with at least a few skeptics. The comic makes a point, during all of Stryker's public appearances, to feature dialogue by at least one or two nervous onlookers who voice some misgivings. Even some of them who seem afraid of mutants comment that Stryker himself is the really scary one. The climactic moment comes when Kitty Pryde confronts Stryker at his hate rally in Madison Square Garden. Stryker pulls a gun on Kitty, but it is stopped by a police officer, who shoots Stryker before he can fire. (The comic does a lot to make it clear that Kitty can get tired enough that she can't "phase," so she might be in real danger here despite her super powers.)
I think in my memory, a lot of the newer X-Men stories make it seem like it's the mutants against everybody. The newest season of the wonderful X-Men '97 cartoon show ended on a cliffhanger in which super-bigot Graydon Creed is elected president, signalling a broad shift against mutant-kind.
But what strikes me is that Claremont seems to be saying, hey, you can fill Madison Square Garden by warping scripture and using cheap rhetorical tricks, but you can't fool everyone, not all of them. Not everybody would go along with a grown man shooting a teenager. Even when Magneto warns Charles, in the epilogue, that Stryker "won" just by introducing his hateful rhetoric into the public sphere, Cyclops is there to offer a counter-argument. Human decency might be in short supply, but there will always be dissenters.
And I believe that, I really do.
I also think that, in our current neo-fascistic age in which a bunch of losers have been indoctrinated by machine-generated racist agit-prop, you could probably fill Madison Square Garden with bigots, and not a decent soul among them.